The people in the political riding of Provencher are “hateful, unsavory and ignorant!” That’s what you might think if you read the second page feature in Tuesday’s Metro newspaper. I had a copy of the Metro handed to me as I boarded the bus early Tuesday morning. I opened it up and read the piece during my transit ride. I found the article unsettling. It describes a video posted by Provencher member of Parliament Ted Falk on his Facebook page. In the video Mr. Falk suggests refugees who cross the border into Canada at Emerson are taking advantage of kind-hearted Canadians. Falk calls on the Liberal government to make their stance on the issue clear.
I had watched Mr. Falk’s video prior to reading the Metro story. I thought there would have been better ways to address the concerns of his Provencher constituents in Emerson. I wished Mr. Falk had adopted a more welcoming and open-minded tone. While expressing his opinion that additional information and a clear policy from the federal government was required in the Emerson situation, he could have also talked about the many concrete ways we can all provide practical assistance to people from war-torn countries. Mr. Falk could have reminded his constituents that at one time most of their families had been refugees too.
The Metro writer says hundreds of people have written accolades about Mr. Falk’s video on his Facebook page and that is true. I scrolled through the nearly four hundred responses and many are written in a fairly reasonable tone. There are some that remind Mr. Falk he needs to be more compassionate. They speculate as to how Jesus might have acted towards ‘the least among us’ who are crossing the border at Emerson. There are also some comments that say very disrespectful and unkind things about Muslims, the prime minster and refugees in general. I agree with the Metro writer that having provided a platform for these kinds of comments Mr. Falk might respond to them in some way. He could delete or moderate inappropriate comments and remind his Facebook followers that informed, rational dialogue is the path to understanding.
One line in the Metro piece stood out for me. “Sadly, Falk’s views are in tune with those held by many of his constituents.” That line makes it seem like the people in Provencher don’t care about refugees or their plight. I know that isn’t true. To balance their reporting on the Falk video the Metro might also have published a photo of the huge sign outside Grace Mennonite Church in Steinbach that welcomes all people as neighbours in both Arabic and English. They might have reported on the refugee families that are currently being sponsored by groups in southeastern Manitoba or have been sponsored in the past. I personally know of many such stories.
Last summer in the coverage leading up to the Pride Parade in Steinbach the media largely ignored the efforts of the people in southeastern Manitoba who have welcomed their LGBTQ neighbours for years and worked hard to make their communities more accepting. Instead they chose to focus on the less supportive comments and actions of local political leaders. Now they are doing the same thing with the refugee situation.
I lived in Mr. Falk’s riding for some four decades. I know it is home to many people who are open-minded, welcoming, well-informed, thoughtful and compassionate. They need to be featured in media reports about Provencher as well in order to provide more balanced coverage.
Pride in Steinbach isn’t Something New
Thoughts on Refugees
My Former Church and the Pope
Filed under Media, Politics