This whole controversy about the statues of famous people and whether they should be removed has me thinking. Should we stop honoring people when we erect statues and rather honor ideas? I’ve featured many statues on this blog of famous Canadians I actually thought were worthy of praise, but now I’m wondering if they all had a dark side? A little research makes it clear many of them did. For example……..
Here I am with Emily Murphy on Parliament Hill in Ottawa. She was instrumental in achieving personhood for Canadian women so they were no longer considered their husbands’ or fathers’ property. Yet according to the Toronto Globe and Mail Emily wrote articles attacking Chinese immigrants, American blacks, Jews and other Eastern Europeans who had chosen Canada as their home.
Here I am in Gambo Newfoundland with a statue of Joey Smallwood. He is credited with bringing Newfoundland into the modern age and into Confederation but there are many people who saw him as autocratic and interested mainly in self promotion. They criticize the way he often sided with bankers and industrialists rather than unions and laborers.
Perhaps it is time to stop honoring people with statues and just honor ideas instead. For example the statue emptyful at the Winnipeg Millenium Library honors the beauty of the wide open spaces of the prairies. Who could quarrel with that?
This sculpture in Quebec City honors the idea of education. An outstretched hand sits on a pile of books. The hand has a feather. This shows how an education helps us learn to read and write and become literate people. Who could quarrel with that?
Perhaps its time to stop honoring people with sculptures and focus on honoring worthwhile ideas instead.